Questions or Comments: amda@tceq.texas.gov
You are here:

Sulfur Dioxide Dispersion Modeling for Howard County

Air dispersion and stochastic modeling methods, files, and data to support the Howard County sulfur dioxide attainment demonstration for the State Implementation Plan (SIP) revision.

A portion of Howard County does not meet the 2010 Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS)Exit the TCEQ. TCEQ has application/pdfdeveloped a plan to demonstrate how the area will meet the SO2 standard. Below is TCEQ's dispersion modeling that was used for developing the plan, including a description of the pollution sources and the surrounding area.

If you have questions about these files, please email amda@tceq.texas.gov with "Howard SO2 Dispersion Modeling Files" in the subject line.

Area Overview 

The Howard County 2010 SO2 NAAQS nonattainment area contains three sites (outlined in blue, yellow, and black on the map), each with multiple sources of SO2 emissions, that are included in the attainment demonstration modeling. The Big Spring Midway monitor, or Continuous Ambient Monitoring Station 1072 (C1072) is required under the Data requirements RuleExit the TCEQ and was sited (green triangle on the map) across North Midway Road approximately 0.15 kilometer to the northeast of the Tokai Plant, to monitor SO2 concentrations. The closest surface and upper air weather stations are located at the Midland International Airport (WBAN 23023). 

A map showing the Howard County sulfur dioxide nonattainment area within Howard County, Texas outlined in red. The Big spring Carbon Black Plant (Tokai), the Big spring Refinery (Delek), and BHER Power Resources (BHER) are three sources of SO2 emissions within the Howard County nonattainment area and are outlined in yellow, blue, and black, respectively, in the figure. A Data Requirements Rule monitor, the Big Spring Midway monitor, or Continuous Ambient Monitoring Station 1072 (C1072), was sited (green triangle on the map) across North Midway Road approximately 0.15 kilometer to the northeast of the Tokai Plant to monitor SO2 concentrations. This monitor is shown as a green triangle in the figure.

Larger Map

Model Configuration

The sources for the Howard County 2010 SO2 NAAQS nonattainment area were modeled with the standard practices outlined in Appendix W, Guideline on Air Quality ModelsExit the TCEQ.

Air Dispersion Model: AERMOD version 21112

AERMOD Preprocessors:

  • AERMET version 21112 to generate meteorological data files.
  • AERMINUTE version 15272 to include measured one-minute wind averages.
  • AERSURFACE version 20060 to determine the surface characteristics for the meteorological station.
  • AERMAP version 18081 to gather elevation data for sources and receptors.
  • The Building Profile Input Program for PRIME (BPIPPRM) version 04274 to calculate building downwash effects.

Meteorological Years Modeled: 2016 through 2020

MC Approach: In the Howard County nonattainment area, four flares at the Delek US Holdings' facility emit SO2 intermittently and randomly during maintenance, startup, and shutdown operations. To better characterize the variability of these sources, TCEQ contracted with Ramboll US Corporation to develop the MC Approach, which uses a Monte Carlo method in conjunction with the recommended air dispersion modeling. The MC approach was used to estimate modeled design values more realistically since dispersion modeling of these sources continually results in unrealistic emission scenarios. The MC approach resulted in TCEQ conducting more than 2 million simulations where the Delek US Holdings' flares were operated randomly to ensure that the Howard County nonattainment area will remain in attainment under the different operating conditions. More information about the MC approach can be found in application/pdfAppendix L of the SIP revision

Background Concentration: The background SO2 concentration used for this modeling was calculated for each hour and season by averaging the 99th percentile hourly values for 2018 through 2020 from the Midlothian Old Fort Worth monitor (C52).

Modeling Data Files

You may download the model runs and control file inputs described below from the TCEQ Air Modeling FTP site. Please use an FTP client software, such as FileZillaExit the TCEQ, to access our public FTP site:

  • FTP address: amdaftp.tceq.texas.gov
  • FTP directory: /SO2/Howard/AERMOD & /SO2/Howard/MC_Approach
  • User ID: anonymous
  • Password: user’s email address

Data available includes:

  • Ancillary inputs (downwash, meteorology, and receptor input data).
  • Run directories containing control files and model output. 

AERMOD and its preprocessor source code and executables are available on the US Environmental Protection Agency's websiteExit the TCEQ

If you would like to request additional data related to the modeling for this SIP revision, please email amda@tceq.texas.gov with "Howard County SO2 Modeling Files - Data Request" in the subject line and specify which data you are requesting.

SIP Revision and Related Appendices 

Documents for the SIP revision and appendices related to this modeling are below:

For more on this SIP Revision, visit the Air Pollution from Sulfur Dioxide webpage.